Pimento Cheese and Tomato Sandwiches

By Kia Damon

Updated May 6, 2026

  • Rachel Vanni for The New York Times. Food Stylist: Barrett Washburne.
Media 1 of 1
Total Time
25 minutes
Prep Time
15 minutes
Cook Time
10 minutes
Rating
5(234)
Comments
Read comments

Every summer, Southerners await the arrival of juicy, ripe tomatoes to make a classic tomato sandwich. This version of the beloved staple swaps in pimento cheese as the creamy companion instead of the typical mayonnaise. The pimento cheese is studded with sharp Cheddar and jalapeño, giving it just enough kick without completely overshadowing the tomato. Choose tomatoes that are ripe but still somewhat firm: You want them to have the structural integrity that prevents a soggy sandwich. While many Southerners prefer plain white bread, you could opt for sourdough or brioche. This recipe is great for parties and group picnics, but don’t feel pressured to only make these for a crowd — the recipe can be easily halved. You could also use the extra to spread on crackers or add to biscuit dough. You’ll end up with four cups of pimento cheese, which will keep in the refrigerator for up to a week. However, the sandwiches are best eaten as soon as they’re assembled.

  • or to save this recipe.

  • Subscriber benefit: Give recipes to anyone

    As a subscriber, you have 10 gift recipes to give each month. Anyone can view them - even nonsubscribers. Learn more.

    Subscribe

  • Share this recipe

  • Print this recipe

    or to print this recipe.

Advertisement

Ingredients

Yield:8 sandwiches

  • 8 ounces cream cheese, softened

  • 8 ounces sharp Cheddar, grated (2 cups) 

  • ½ cup mayonnaise

  • 1 (8-ounce) jar pimentos, drained and minced (1 ½  cups)

  • 1 jalapeño, seeded and diced

  • 1 teaspoon mustard powder

  • 1 teaspoon paprika

  • ½ teaspoon ground cayenne 

  • Salt

  • 2 large heirloom tomatoes (preferably ripe but firm)

  • 16 slices white bread

Ingredient Substitution Guide
Nutritional analysis per serving

33 grams carbs; 41 milligrams cholesterol; 405 calories; 6 grams monosaturated fat; 8 grams polyunsaturated fat; 9 grams saturated fat; 26 grams fat; 4 grams fiber; 499 milligrams sodium; 11 grams protein; 7 grams sugar

Note: The information shown is Edamam’s estimate based on available ingredients and preparation. It should not be considered a substitute for a professional nutritionist’s advice.

Powered by

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    Mix the cheeses, mayonnaise, pimentos, jalapeño, mustard powder, paprika and cayenne in a large bowl until thoroughly combined. Season with salt to taste. Cut the tomatoes crosswise into ½-inch-thick slices. Toast the bread.

  2. Step 2

    To assemble each sandwich, spread ¼ cup of the cheese mixture on both slices of bread, add a slice of tomato, sprinkle lightly with salt and close the sandwich. Slice into your preferred shape and eat immediately.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Comment on this recipe and see it here.

Ratings

5 out of 5
234 user ratings
Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Comments

Susan C.

Not a classic and to our taste seriously over-seasoned, because p.c. is best when simple. Tomatoes are optional and cream cheese should never appear. Brioche? Never!

Kayandallie

I add some cooked bacon slices to the pimento cheese and tomato sandwich and grill it like for grilled cheese. Makes an oozy but decadent sandwich.

Nick

This is a poor rendition of pimento cheese that attempts to doll up one of the simplest pleasures in eating. Beyond making your own mayo - which is always worth it - it's just sharp cheddar, pimento and some light seasoning (salt, pepper, pinch of cayenne). It should be toothsome, owing to a large grate, rather than smooth. It's not a dip. This is virtually the only reason I still buy white bread now and again.

Megan

I’ve never eaten pimento cheese before (due to texture issues) do I went into this with a side eye. We added some chopped candied jalapeños and slathered it onto texas toast then toasted it for a grilled cheese edition. Yum! Id make it again.

Karen

Good grief - this is so complicated. Count this Virginian with the “simpler is better” folks and skip the cream cheese! Sharp cheddar, some good mayo (I prefer Hellman’s” and a bit of Tabasco. Let it sit overnight. Dead ripe tomatoes a must!

PJ

This recipe feels like a fever-dream. "sharp cheddar and jalapeño, giving it just enough kick" ignores that the recipe calls for a pile of punchy spices that overpowers the standing of the fresh pepper. The quantity, beyond any arguments on mere addition, of cream cheese makes this mushy and unsatisfying to bite into. Cannot recommend as-is.

Private comments are only visible to you.

Recipe Tags

or to save this recipe.