Mushroom Smash Burgers
Updated March 27, 2025
- Total Time
- 20 minutes
- Prep Time
- 5 minutes
- Cook Time
- 15 minutes
- Rating
- Comments
- Read comments
Advertisement
Ingredients
¼ cup neutral oil, such as grapeseed, plus more as needed
1 teaspoon onion powder
Salt and black pepper
4 large portobello mushrooms, stems removed, wiped clean
4 slices sharp Cheddar
2 hamburger buns
Toppings (such as lettuce, sliced tomato, sliced onion, and pickles) and condiments (mayonnaise, ketchup, and mustard), as desired
Preparation
- Step 1
In a small bowl, stir together the oil and onion powder and season with salt and pepper. Score the top of the mushrooms with an X. Coat the mushrooms all over with the oil mixture.
- Step 2
Heat a large cast-iron skillet over medium-high. Add the mushrooms and place a second heavy skillet on top of the mushrooms. (Wrap the top skillet in foil for easier clean-up.) Cook, flipping the mushrooms every two minutes. Once the mushrooms are flattened, about 4 minutes in, occasionally press down firmly on the top skillet to promote browning. (If you do this before they are flat, you risk splitting the mushroom.) Continue flipping and pressing until the mushrooms are browned and thin, 8 to 10 minutes, reducing the heat if they begin to char. If the mushrooms become matte and wrinkly, drizzle on another tablespoon of oil.
- Step 3
Reduce heat to low and top with the cheese. Cover with a lid or sheet pan and cook until the cheese is melted, 1 to 2 minutes. Add two mushrooms per bun and desired toppings and condiments.
Private Notes
Comments
DELICIOUS ACCIDENT AHEAD!! Husband bought 2 lbs of ‘Baby Bellas’ instead of the large caps. Followed instructions anyway. Took the tiny smashed bellas and layered in 6 patty-sized mounds with shredded parm and mozz and grated garlic. Baked this at 425 for 10 min. The resulting ‘Frico Smashies’ were delicious!! Worked just like patties!
No mention of portobello gills? Should they be scraped off or left in?
Add carmelized onions Made 6/24. EXCELLENT
Add caramelized onions. and cut a 1 cm slice of ultra-firm tofu off a block of the stuff, gently squeezed out what little water it contained (being careful not to break the slab). I did the portobello, then removed it and applied the onion/oil mix (adding garlic powder, paprika, and a little cayenne) and fried the tofu slab golden on both sides. Assembled the burger with the tofu under the shroom.
LOVED these! My husband often has texture issues with cooked mushrooms, so I did burgers with one regular smashburger patty topped with one of the mushroom patties, glued together with cheese in the middle. Hands down the absolute best mushroom swiss burger I've ever had, without any of the usual slipping and sliding of smaller mushroom pieces. Second time around, I also cooked whole slices of onion (like how you can get "whole grilled onion" from In-N-Out) and put those between the mushroom and patty with a second slice of cheese (burger, cheese, onion, cheese, mushroom) and it was even better. Tip: if you do a (shallow!) crosshatch across the tops of the portobellos instead of just an X, you can use a Dutch oven as the weight for the first 6-8 minutes and then let all the excess moisture evaporate during the final (unweighted) 2-4 minutes.
This was a delicious burger. Instead of paprika, I used sumac...love its flavor, and I used one mushroom per burger. Costco's square ciabatta buns lightly toasted held the arugula, sautéed onions, tomatoes, pickles, cheese & condiments very well. I think a brioche or burger bun would have been too fragile. The cooking method was great...foil on the smaller cast iron was a great suggestion in comments. What a great way to have a way better-than-beef burger for a very healthy choice!!

